John Borstlap (b. 1950) is a composer and author on cultural subjects, covering music and the visual arts. Although born in the Netherlands, his music is rooted in the German classical tradition, the countries being very close.
He studied at the Rotterdam Conservatory and took a Masters Degree at the University of Cambridge (England). His Violin Concerto won prizes at the Prince Pierre Competition in Monaco and the Wieniawski Competition in Poznan (Poland). His chamber music is performed in the Netherlands and abroad, and has been recorded for radio broadcasts. Performances of his ‘Sinfonia’ (1st symphony) in 1990 by the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra under Hartmut Haenchen established John Borstlap’s reputation as a distinctive orchestral composer of classically-orientated music. In 1997 a CD of chamber works was issued in England (‘Hyperion’s Dream’, Albany Records), which the composer was invited to introduce on national Dutch TV.
In 1998 John Borstlap organised, with the generous support of NOG Verzekeringen (director: Ton Boersma), a chamber music festival ‘Tradition and Renewal’ in Haarlem with internationally renowned performers. Since the première in Manchester in 2001 by the London-based New Queen’s Hall Orchestra of an elaboration of a Wagner sketch, ‘Psyche’, various European orchestras followed with performances, among which the Orchestre National de Montpellier.
John Borstlap wrote various articles on contemporary music and wider cultural issues, which have been published in the professional magazines in the Netherlands and abroad. In 2001 his groundbreaking essay ‘Recreating the Classical Tradition’ was published in the volume ‘Reviving the Muse’ (Claridge Press, UK 2001). Also he has been involved in the organisation of a music conference ‘Redefining Musical Identities’ at the University of Amsterdam in 2002, and was a speaker at the international conference ‘Music and Patronage in the Low Countries’ of the Royal Society of Dutch Music History in 2010, also at the University of Amsterdam.
In 2002 he set up, together with two collegues, the Composers Group Amsterdam. The group’s artistic credo can be summarised as the ‘Renewal of Cultural Traditions’, bridging the gap between new music and traditional performance culture. In February 2003 the group featured in a live programme on Dutch national TV and in July 2004 the German national radio station ARD dedicated a programme to CGA’s music and ideas: ‘Visions of a new European music’. The group’s proposal to the Dutch Ministery for Culture in 2003 for a new way of organising the state subsidies for new music, has set a partial reform in motion in 2006, which antagonized many composers in Holland who enjoyed privileged treatment in the old system, due to their direct personal involvement in the selection process.
Borstlap’s short opera ‘Flucht nach Kythera’ has been accepted for semi-scenic production by the chamber orchestra Sinfonia Rotterdam for future production. Meanwhile, this ‘mono drama’ has also found the interest of various German opera houses where it is currently under negotiation.
John Borstlap’s ideas about new possibilities of the classical tradition in the 21st century, which are shared by other composers like David Matthews, Nicolas Bacri, Richard Dubugnon, Karol Beffa, Alexander Smelkov (and already pioneered by George Rochberg and David del Tredici in the seventies) are part of a wider current debate in art aesthetics as shown by the work of Alexander Nehamas (‘The Place of Beauty in a World of Art’), Roger Scruton (‘Beauty’), Paolo Euron (‘Art, Beauty and Imitation’), Denis Dutton (‘The Art Instinct’) and Andreas Dorschel (‘Vom Preis des Fortschritts’), and the work of the German theorist and composer Wolfgang Andreas Schultz (‘Damit die Musik nicht aufhört’, ‘Avantgarde – Trauma – Spiritualität’). Recently John Borstlap finished a short book about new classical music: ‘The Classical Revolution’ (the Scarecrow Press, New York 2013), which was well received and provoked some intense debate in the Neue Zeitschrift für Musik and the Neue Musikzeitung, the two prominent music magazines in Germany.
Borstlap’s advocacy of a fair and acceptable financing system for composers in Holland to replace the existing procedures as operating at the centralized and monopolizing Dutch music fund, resulted in 2012 in a court case when an application for financing a commission was rejected, as happened to him often in the past. In the proceedings, the fund was shown-up to be incompetent, biassed, and careless in treating Borstlap’s application, but the court ruled that the fund did not need to draw any conclusion from this outcome, i.e. paying for the commission and consider further reforms of the system. In the ensuing appeal procedure at the Supreme Court, where Borstlap had produced irrefutable documents from international experts supporting his claim to be paid for his work, the court kept these documents out of the procedure by retroactively changing the deadline for sending-in such material, so that the fund could be protected from Borstlap’s claim. From the following exchanges between Borstlap and the fund, and the Minister responsibile for the subsidy system, appeared that the fund has been given full endorsement by both the Minister and the legal system to ignore Borstlap’s international recognition and professional functioning in musical practice, which means that the fund has been legally empowered to reject all future applications for funding Borstlap’s music and is relieved from any obligation to handle such applications with care and competence. In fact, the attempt to claim a right to be paid for his work by the Dutch funding structure specially set-up for this purpose, led to the definite exclusion of Borstlap’s music from payment by this system.
In spite of these troubles, in the spring of 2013 John Borstlap finished his third symphony, due to be premiered by the Kammersymphonie Berlin in one of the future seasons in the Berlin Philharmonie. Other orchestral performances are currently under negotiation in the USA, Germany and Vienna.
In the autumn of 2014, the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra and the Dallas Symphony Orchestra together commissioned Borstlap for a new work: ‘Feierliche Abendmusik’ (‘Solemn Night Music’), which was successfully premiered in March and June 2016 by the respective orchestras under international star conductor Jaap van Zweden. In January 2017 John Borstlap was appointed Senior Research Fellow at the Future Symphony Institute in Baltimore.